The debate around India’s crypto tax laws has intensified. Experts argue that lowering the one percent TDS on crypto transactions could yield substantial economic benefits. This blog explores the implications of the current tax regime and the potential advantages of revising it.
Current Crypto Tax Landscape in India
Since 2022, India has imposed a 30 percent tax on all crypto gains. Additionally, a one percent TDS applies to every transaction. The Finance Ministry aims to track all crypto transactions through TDS, maintaining transparency in a largely anonymous market. This stringent tax policy has placed India at the top of the list of countries with the highest tax rates. The one percent TDS, in particular, stands out as unique, with no other major economy implementing such a withholding tax.
Harsh Tax Laws and Their Consequences
The current tax regime in India is notably severe. The 30 percent tax on profits is higher than in comparable economies like Ukraine, Canada, and the US. Moreover, the inability to offset and carry forward losses makes the tax impact even harsher. This discrimination is not present in other industry sectors within India.
These strict laws have led to a significant decline in these activities. The number of active users on Indian exchanges dropped by 81 percent in 2023. Many investors now prefer foreign exchanges to circumvent these regulations. Consequently, Indian exchanges face reduced user engagement and revenue, forcing them to implement cost-cutting measures.
Potential Benefits of Reducing TDS
Lowering the one percent TDS could offer multiple benefits. Firstly, it would reduce the overall TDS refunds, thereby increasing government revenue through capital gains taxes. Secondly, it would enhance transaction monitoring by Virtual Asset Service Providers (VASPs). These providers can then focus on regulatory compliance and security improvements.
A reduction in TDS could also attract more investors to Indian crypto exchanges. Increased participation would boost the overall crypto market activity in India, leading to higher transaction volumes and, consequently, more tax revenue. This change would align India more closely with global tax practices, potentially attracting international investments.
Economic Projections and Recommendations
A recent report by the Centre for Tax Laws and NALSAR University of Law outlines the economic benefits of revising crypto tax laws. According to the report, India could generate Rs. 5,144 crores through capital gains by 2027 if the country revises its crypto laws. The report recommends lowering the TDS rate to stimulate market activity and increase tax revenues.
Additionally, the report suggests that reducing the TDS rate would improve transaction monitoring and compliance. VASPs would find it easier to track and report transactions, enhancing transparency and reducing illegal activities in the crypto market. These changes would foster a healthier and more robust crypto ecosystem in India.
Follow for more: TCS and Xerox Partner to Build an AI-Powered Enterprise Platform
The Road Ahead for India’s Crypto Tax Policy
As of now, the Indian government has not indicated any plans to revise the crypto tax laws. Earlier this year, Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman’s interim budget did not address the crypto sector. The government’s silence on this matter leaves the crypto community in a state of uncertainty.
However, the growing discourse around the need for tax reform suggests that change might be on the horizon. Policymakers must consider the potential economic benefits of reducing the TDS rate. By doing so, they could support the growth of the crypto industry in India while also boosting tax revenues.
Conclusion
India’s current crypto tax laws are among the harshest in the world. The one percent TDS on every transaction, coupled with a 30 percent tax on gains, has stifled the growth of the crypto market. Reducing the TDS rate could rejuvenate the industry, increase government revenue, and improve transaction transparency. As the debate continues, the potential benefits of tax reform become increasingly clear. Policymakers must weigh these benefits and consider revising the current tax regime to support the burgeoning crypto sector in India.
Source: https://www.gadgets360.com/
